2016 Rookie of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Berry | NL | Seager | Maeda | Diaz |
| Alyson Footer | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Andrew Gruman | NL | Seager | Turner | Diaz |
| Anthony Castrovince | AL | Sanchez | Fulmer | Naquin |
| Anthony DiComo | NL | Seager | Maeda | Turner |
| Barney Hutchinson | NL | Seager | Story | Turner |
| Benjamin Hochman | NL | Seager | Maeda | Turner |
| Beth Harris | NL | Seager | Maeda | Diaz |
| Brian Golden | AL | Sanchez | Fulmer | Devenski |
| Brittany Ghiroli | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Diaz |
| Bruce Levine | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Diaz |
| Bryan Hoch | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Carl Steward | NL | Seager | Turner | Story |
| Charles Odum | NL | Seager | Story | Turner |
| Chase Hughes | NL | Seager | Story | Turner |
| Chris Haft | NL | Seager | Turner | Story |
| Dan Szymborski | NL | Seager | Turner | Diaz |
| Dave Campbell | AL | Fulmer | Devenski | Sanchez |
| David Brown | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Anderson |
| David Wilhelm | NL | Seager | Maeda | Diaz |
| Eddie Matz | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Devenski |
| Erik Boland | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Evan Drellich | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Devenski |
| George Sipple | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Greg Beacham | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Mazara |
| Greg Johns | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Diaz |
| Gregor Chisholm | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Hideki Okuda | NL | Seager | Maeda | Turner |
| Jack Etkin | NL | Seager | Story | Diaz |
| Jamal Collier | NL | Seager | Turner | Diaz |
| james_in_to | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Jane Lee | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Jeff Sanders | NL | Seager | Turner | Maeda |
| Jeff Sullivan | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Jesse Rogers | NL | Seager | Story | Diaz |
| Jesse Sanchez | NL | Seager | Maeda | Diaz |
| Joe Posnanski | AL | Sanchez | Fulmer | Anderson |
| John Fay | NL | Seager | Diaz | Turner |
| John Manuel | NL | Seager | Turner | Maeda |
| Jonathan Mayo | NL | Seager | Turner | Maeda |
| Jorge Ebro | NL | Seager | Story | Diaz |
| Keith Law | NL | Seager | Turner | Gray |
| Keizo Konishi | NL | Seager | Maeda | Diaz |
| Kevin Sherrington | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Kirk Kenney | NL | Seager | Maeda | Story |
| Kristie Rieken | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Marc Topkin | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Maria Guardado | NL | Seager | Maeda | Turner |
| Matt Kawahara | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Meghan Montemurro | NL | Seager | Turner | Oh |
| Noah Trister | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Devenski |
| Patrick Borzi | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Mazara |
| Roger Mooney | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Naquin |
| Ryan Lawrence | NL | Seager | Maeda | Turner |
| Sahadev Sharma | NL | Seager | Turner | Matz |
| Scott Lauber | AL | Sanchez | Fulmer | Naquin |
| Scott MacArthur | AL | Fulmer | Naquin | Sanchez |
| Scott Merkin | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Diaz |
| Stefan Stevenson | AL | Fulmer | Naquin | Mazara |
| Tom Withers | AL | Fulmer | Sanchez | Mazara |
| Tony DeMarco | NL | Seager | Story | Maeda |