2014 Rookie of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Barney Hutchinson | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Anderson |
| Bob Nightengale | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Brian Golden | NL | Hamilton | deGrom | Wong |
| Brian MacPherson | AL | Abreu | Tanaka | McHugh |
| Brian McNally | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Inciarte |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Hendricks |
| Carl Steward | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Panik |
| Clark Spencer | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Familia |
| Dan Martin | AL | Abreu | Betances | Ventura |
| Daniel Brown | AL | Abreu | McHugh | Shoemaker |
| David Wilhelm | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Dick Scanlon | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Tanaka |
| Evan Drellich | AL | Abreu | McHugh | Betances |
| Fred Mitchell | NL | Hamilton | deGrom | Wong |
| George A. King III | AL | Abreu | Betances | Ventura |
| George Sipple | AL | Abreu | McHugh | Ventura |
| Gil LeBreton | AL | Abreu | Betances | Ventura |
| Gregg Wong | AL | Abreu | Santana | Shoemaker |
| Guy Curtright | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Panik |
| Jack Etkin | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Inciarte |
| james_in_to | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Jeff Miller | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Tanaka |
| Jeff Passan | AL | Abreu | McHugh | Ventura |
| Jerry Crasnick | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Giles |
| Joe Ostermeier | NL | deGrom | Giles | Hamilton |
| Joe Reedy | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Betances |
| Joel Sherman | AL | Abreu | McHugh | Tanaka |
| John Erardi | NL | Hamilton | deGrom | Inciarte |
| John Finger | NL | deGrom | Giles | Hamilton |
| John Maffei | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Jonah Keri | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Giles |
| Joseph Smith | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Betances |
| Justin McGuire | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Karen Price | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Keith Law | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | d'Arnaud |
| Ken Davidoff | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Inciarte |
| Lynn Henning | AL | Abreu | Betances | Castellanos |
| Marla Ridenour | AL | Abreu | Betances | Holt |
| Matt Calkins | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Hendricks |
| Mel Antonen | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Odorizzi |
| Michael Martinez | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Tanaka |
| Mike Rutsey | AL | Abreu | McHugh | Shoemaker |
| Pat Stoetzer | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Springer |
| Patrick Borzi | AL | Abreu | Tanaka | Betances |
| Paul Sullivan | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Betances |
| Paul White | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | d'Arnaud |
| Phil Rogers | NL | Hamilton | deGrom | Wong |
| Ray Ratto | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Panik |
| Rick Gosselin | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Tanaka |
| Roger Rubin | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Familia |
| Ron Cook | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Ryan Divish | AL | Abreu | Betances | Shoemaker |
| Scot Gregor | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Ventura |
| Sean McAdam | AL | Abreu | Betances | McHugh |
| Shi Davidi | AL | Abreu | Ventura | McHugh |
| Steve Kroner | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Tanaka |
| Takanao Ishii | AL | Abreu | Shoemaker | Tanaka |
| Todd Dybas | AL | Abreu | Tanaka | Betances |
| Todd Rosiak | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |
| Tom D'Angelo | NL | deGrom | Wong | Hamilton |
| Tom Haudricourt | NL | deGrom | Hamilton | Wong |