2016 Manager of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| AJ Cassavell | NL | Maddon | Roberts | Mattingly |
| Angel H. Verdejo Jr. | AL | Showalter | Francona | Banister |
| Aurelio Moreno | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Barry Bloom | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Chad Jennings | AL | Francona | Farrell | Showalter |
| Chris Assenheimer | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| Christina Kahrl | AL | Francona | Banister | Girardi |
| Dan Myers | AL | Banister | Showalter | Francona |
| Daniel Brown | NL | Baker | Maddon | Roberts |
| Dave Skretta | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| David Barron | AL | Banister | Francona | Showalter |
| David Ginsburg | AL | Banister | Showalter | Francona |
| David Lennon | NL | Baker | Roberts | Collins |
| Drew Olson | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Eno Sarris | AL | Farrell | Showalter | Francona |
| Gil LeBreton | AL | Francona | Farrell | Girardi |
| Gordon Wittenmyer | NL | Roberts | Collins | Baker |
| Hal Bodley | AL | Farrell | Francona | Banister |
| J.P. Hoornstra | NL | Maddon | Roberts | Baker |
| james_in_to | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Janie McCauley | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Jared Diamond | AL | Francona | Banister | Showalter |
| Jay Paris | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Jeff Blair | AL | Francona | Girardi | Banister |
| Jill Painter Lopez | AL | Francona | Showalter | Banister |
| Jim Alexander | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| Jim Caple | AL | Francona | Banister | Showalter |
| JJ Cooper | NL | Maddon | Baker | Roberts |
| Joe Frisaro | NL | Baker | Roberts | Collins |
| Joe Kay | NL | Maddon | Roberts | Baker |
| John Perrotto | NL | Roberts | Baker | Collins |
| Jonah Keri | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Jose de Jesus Ortiz | NL | Roberts | Baker | Mattingly |
| Ken Davidoff | NL | Roberts | Baker | Collins |
| Ken Rosenthal | AL | Francona | Showalter | Banister |
| Lynn Henning | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| Mark Schmetzer | NL | Collins | Maddon | Roberts |
| Marly Rivera | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Martin Fennelly | AL | Francona | Showalter | Banister |
| Matt Breen | NL | Maddon | Roberts | Baker |
| Matthew B. Mowery | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| Mel Antonen | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Michael Silverman | AL | Francona | Showalter | Farrell |
| Mike Harrington | AL | Francona | Showalter | Banister |
| Pat Reusse | AL | Showalter | Francona | Banister |
| Paul Sullivan | NL | Baker | Maddon | Roberts |
| Pete Abraham | AL | Francona | Showalter | Farrell |
| Phil Rogers | AL | Banister | Francona | Showalter |
| R.B. Fallstrom | NL | Maddon | Collins | Roberts |
| Ron Cook | NL | Maddon | Roberts | Collins |
| Ryan Fagan | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Ryan Lewis | AL | Francona | Farrell | Showalter |
| Ryota Ichikawa | NL | Roberts | Maddon | Baker |
| Stephen Gross | NL | Roberts | Baker | Maddon |
| Stephen Hawkins | AL | Francona | Banister | Showalter |
| Tim Booth | AL | Francona | Banister | Servais |
| Tim Kawakami | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| Tom Verducci | NL | Roberts | Collins | Baker |
| Tracy Ringolsby | NL | Collins | Baker | Roberts |
| Vahe Gregorian | AL | Francona | Banister | Farrell |
| William Lloyd Ladson | NL | Maddon | Baker | Roberts |