2015 Manager of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Andy McCullough | AL | Banister | Yost | Molitor |
| Bill West | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Hurdle |
| Bob Nightengale | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Bruce Levine | AL | Girardi | Molitor | Banister |
| Chad Jennings | AL | Hinch | Banister | Molitor |
| Charles Odum | NL | Maddon | Collins | Matheny |
| Chase Hughes | NL | Maddon | Collins | Matheny |
| Chris Jenkins | NL | Maddon | Collins | Hurdle |
| Daniel Brown | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Dave Campbell | AL | Banister | Gibbons | Molitor |
| David Barron | AL | Hinch | Banister | Molitor |
| David Brown | AL | Molitor | Banister | Yost |
| Dennis Manoloff | AL | Banister | Gibbons | Girardi |
| Dick Scanlon | AL | Banister | Hinch | Molitor |
| Doug Padilla | AL | Banister | Gibbons | Molitor |
| Erik Boland | AL | Molitor | Banister | Hinch |
| Evan Drellich | AL | Hinch | Banister | Molitor |
| Fred Mitchell | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Gil LeBreton | AL | Banister | Hinch | Molitor |
| Gordon Edes | AL | Hinch | Banister | Yost |
| Greg Beacham | AL | Banister | Hinch | Gibbons |
| Guy Curtright | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Hideki Okuda | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Jack McCaffery | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Mattingly |
| Jake Kaplan | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| James Schmehl | AL | Banister | Gibbons | Hinch |
| Jay Paris | NL | Maddon | Collins | Hurdle |
| Jerry Crasnick | AL | Banister | Hinch | Molitor |
| Jill Painter Lopez | AL | Banister | Hinch | Scioscia |
| Jim Caple | AL | Banister | Molitor | Hinch |
| Joe Ostermeier | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Jonah Keri | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Hurdle |
| Katsushi Nagao | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Ken Davidoff | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Kevin Sherrington | AL | Banister | Hinch | Yost |
| Mark Schmetzer | NL | Collins | Maddon | Matheny |
| Matthew Ehalt | NL | Collins | Matheny | Maddon |
| Mel Antonen | AL | Girardi | Hinch | Molitor |
| Mike Rutsey | AL | Hinch | Gibbons | Banister |
| Molly Knight | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Hurdle |
| Nick Groke | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Hurdle |
| Nobuyuki Kobayashi | AL | Hinch | Banister | Gibbons |
| Octavio Sequera | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Pat Reusse | AL | Banister | Hinch | Molitor |
| Paul Daugherty | NL | Maddon | Collins | Hurdle |
| R.B. Fallstrom | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Robert MacLeod | AL | Gibbons | Hinch | Yost |
| Ryan Lewis | AL | Banister | Hinch | Molitor |
| Scott Bordow | NL | Collins | Maddon | Matheny |
| Scott Lauber | AL | Hinch | Banister | Molitor |
| Scott Ostler | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Bochy |
| Stephen Nesbitt | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Hurdle |
| Steve Kroner | AL | Banister | Hinch | Girardi |
| Tim Kawakami | AL | Hinch | Molitor | Banister |
| Tom D'Angelo | NL | Maddon | Collins | Matheny |
| Tom Gage | AL | Banister | Hinch | Yost |
| Tom Haudricourt | NL | Matheny | Maddon | Collins |
| Tom Jones | AL | Banister | Hinch | Molitor |
| Tom Schad | NL | Maddon | Matheny | Collins |
| Tom Verducci | NL | Maddon | Collins | Matheny |