2012 Manager of the Year Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amanda Housenick | NL | Bochy | Gonzalez | Johnson |
| Anthony Andro | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Washington |
| Asuka Brown | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Maddon |
| Aurelio Moreno | NL | Bochy | Baker | Johnson |
| Bill Center | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Black |
| Bill Madden | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Bob Dutton | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Ventura |
| Bob Hunter | NL | Baker | Johnson | Bochy |
| Bob Nightengale | NL | Baker | Johnson | Bochy |
| Bruce Levine | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Carl Steward | NL | Bochy | Baker | Johnson |
| Carlos Alvarado | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Chris Assenheimer | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Ventura |
| Chris Iott | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Girardi |
| David Lennon | NL | Johnson | Baker | Matheny |
| Erik Boland | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Maddon |
| Gil LeBreton | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Gregg Patton | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Leyland |
| Henry Schulman | NL | Bochy | Johnson | Baker |
| Jack Curry | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Jack Etkin | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Baker | Johnson | Bochy |
| james_in_to | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Jay Paris | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Jeff Blair | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Girardi |
| Jeff Miller | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Maddon |
| Jill Painter Lopez | NL | Johnson | Gonzalez | Baker |
| Jim Henneman | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Joe Lemire | NL | Johnson | Baker | Gonzalez |
| Joe Ostermeier | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Karen Price | NL | Johnson | Baker | Gonzalez |
| Marc Topkin | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Maddon |
| Matt Kawahara | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Girardi |
| Matthew B. Mowery | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Ventura |
| Mel Antonen | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Girardi |
| Michael Hunt | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Michael Silverman | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Mike Berardino | NL | Johnson | Gonzalez | Bochy |
| Mike Kerwick | NL | Johnson | Baker | Gonzalez |
| Mike Rutsey | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Maddon |
| Naoko Sato | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Leyland |
| Nathan Fenno | NL | Johnson | Baker | Gonzalez |
| Nicole Poell | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Washington |
| Pat Reusse | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Maddon |
| Paul Daugherty | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Pete Abraham | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Peter Caldera | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Girardi |
| Phil Rogers | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Richard Justice | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Roger Mooney | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Ventura |
| Ron Cook | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Ryan Lawrence | NL | Johnson | Gonzalez | Baker |
| Sheldon Ocker | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Stan McNeal | NL | Johnson | Bochy | Baker |
| Susan Shemanske | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Thom Loverro | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Tim Kawakami | AL | Melvin | Showalter | Maddon |
| Tom Powers | AL | Showalter | Melvin | Ventura |
| Tom Timmermann | NL | Johnson | Baker | Bochy |
| Toni Ginnetti | NL | Baker | Bochy | Gonzalez |
| Tracy Ringolsby | NL | Baker | Bochy | Johnson |