2018 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Berry | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Alex Pavlovic | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Andrew Wagner | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Freeland | Nola | Hader |
| Anthony Castrovince | AL | Verlander | Snell | Kluber | Sale | Bauer |
| Anthony DiComo | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Anthony Fenech | AL | Verlander | Snell | Cole | Kluber | Diaz |
| Bill Madden | AL | Snell | Kluber | Treinen | Verlander | Severino |
| Bobby Nightengale | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Brittany Ghiroli | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Bauer |
| Chris McCosky | AL | Verlander | Snell | Kluber | Sale | Cole |
| David Brown | AL | Verlander | Snell | Sale | Bauer | Kluber |
| David Ginsburg | AL | Verlander | Snell | Kluber | Sale | Cole |
| Erik Boland | AL | Snell | Verlander | Sale | Kluber | Cole |
| George A. King III | AL | Snell | Sale | Verlander | Kluber | Diaz |
| Greg Johns | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Cole |
| Gregor Chisholm | AL | Snell | Verlander | Sale | Bauer | Kluber |
| Henry Schulman | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Hideki Okuda | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Mikolas |
| J.P. Hoornstra | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Freeland |
| Jack Etkin | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Mikolas |
| James Fegan | AL | Verlander | Snell | Sale | Kluber | Cole |
| Janie McCauley | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Treinen |
| Jason Mastrodonato | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Treinen |
| Jeff Sullivan | AL | Verlander | Snell | Cole | Treinen | Kluber |
| Jenifer Langosch | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Freeland |
| Jerry Crasnick | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Jim Ingraham | AL | Verlander | Kluber | Snell | Cole | Sale |
| Joe Frisaro | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Mikolas |
| John Maffei | NL | Scherzer | deGrom | Mikolas | Nola | Freeland |
| John Perrotto | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Hader |
| John Shea | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Treinen | Cole |
| Katsushi Nagao | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Ken Rosenthal | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Mikolas |
| Kristie Rieken | AL | Verlander | Snell | Sale | Cole | Kluber |
| LaVelle E. Neal III | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Treinen | Sale |
| Levi Weaver | AL | Snell | Verlander | Sale | Kluber | Diaz |
| Mark Bowman | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Foltynewicz |
| Mark Didtler | AL | Snell | Kluber | Verlander | Sale | Treinen |
| Mark Gonzales | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Mikolas | Freeland |
| Mark Saxon | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Mikolas |
| Mark Sheldon | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Hader | Freeland |
| Meghan Montemurro | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Freeland |
| Mike Berardino | AL | Verlander | Sale | Snell | Cole | Bauer |
| Paul Sullivan | AL | Snell | Kluber | Verlander | Sale | Cole |
| Pete Abraham | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Bauer | Sale |
| Richard Justice | AL | Verlander | Snell | Cole | Sale | Bauer |
| Rob Longley | AL | Snell | Verlander | Sale | Kluber | Cole |
| Ryan Fagan | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Freeland |
| Sam Mellinger | AL | Verlander | Snell | Bauer | Sale | Kluber |
| Scott Lauber | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Mikolas |
| Scott Miller | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Foltynewicz | Freeland |
| Steve Gilbert | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Steven Wine | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Mikolas |
| T.R. Sullivan | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Cole | Diaz |
| Thomas Harding | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Freeland | Lester | Nola |
| Tim Britton | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Tim Brown | AL | Verlander | Snell | Sale | Kluber | Cole |
| Todd Rosiak | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Mikolas |
| Yuichi Matsushita | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Treinen |
| Zach Buchanan | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Corbin | Freeland |