2016 Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alex Pavlovic | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Hendricks | Kershaw |
| Anthony Fenech | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sale | Kluber | Britton |
| Bernie Wilson | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Bill Chastain | AL | Porcello | Britton | Kluber | Sale | Tanaka |
| Brendan Kennedy | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sanchez | Tanaka | Kluber |
| Bruce Miles | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Syndergaard | Fernandez |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Hendricks | Cueto |
| Chris McCosky | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Britton |
| Christopher Smith | AL | Porcello | Verlander | Kluber | Britton | Happ |
| Craig Davis | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Fernandez | Kershaw |
| Dan Hayes | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sale | Kluber | Britton |
| Dave Cameron | NL | Kershaw | Scherzer | Syndergaard | Hendricks | Fernandez |
| Doug Padilla | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Kershaw | Fernandez |
| Fred Goodall | AL | Porcello | Kluber | Happ | Britton | Sanchez |
| Gerry Fraley | AL | Porcello | Kluber | Britton | Verlander | Sanchez |
| Guy Curtright | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Kershaw | Bumgarner |
| Ian Browne | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sale | Kluber | Britton |
| J.P. Hoornstra | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Scherzer | Syndergaard | Hendricks |
| Jack Etkin | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Jack Magruder | NL | Hendricks | Lester | Bumgarner | Scherzer | Cueto |
| Jake Kaplan | AL | Verlander | Kluber | Porcello | Sale | Tanaka |
| james_in_to | AL | Verlander | Kluber | Porcello | Sale | Quintana |
| Jeff Wilson | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Britton |
| Jeffrey Flanagan | AL | Kluber | Porcello | Verlander | Sale | Fulmer |
| Jenifer Langosch | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Kershaw | Bumgarner |
| Jim Salisbury | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Cueto | Hendricks |
| Joe Stiglich | AL | Britton | Porcello | Verlander | Kluber | Sale |
| Joel Sherman | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Kershaw | Hendricks | Bumgarner |
| John Maffei | NL | Lester | Scherzer | Hendricks | Arrieta | Cueto |
| John McGrath | AL | Britton | Porcello | Kluber | Happ | Verlander |
| John Shea | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Britton | Tanaka |
| Jon Heyman | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Kershaw | Fernandez |
| Jordan Bastian | AL | Verlander | Sale | Porcello | Kluber | Quintana |
| Jorge Ortiz | NL | Scherzer | Bumgarner | Hendricks | Lester | Cueto |
| Katsushi Nagao | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Cueto | Hendricks |
| KeithBuikema | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Kershaw | Fernandez |
| KeithBuikema | AL | Britton | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Happ |
| LaVelle E. Neal III | AL | Kluber | Porcello | Verlander | Happ | Sale |
| Mark Saxon | NL | Scherzer | Syndergaard | Lester | Hendricks | Fernandez |
| Mark Whicker | AL | Britton | Porcello | Verlander | Kluber | Sanchez |
| Mark Zuckerman | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Matt Snyder | NL | Hendricks | Scherzer | Cueto | Lester | Bumgarner |
| Matthew Ehalt | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Kershaw | Bumgarner |
| Mike Berardino | AL | Verlander | Britton | Miller | Kluber | Porcello |
| MoiseKapenda Bower | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Britton |
| Peter Caldera | AL | Porcello | Kluber | Happ | Britton | Verlander |
| Rich Dubroff | AL | Britton | Porcello | Verlander | Kluber | Sale |
| Rob Biertempfel | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Hendricks | Roark |
| Roch Kubatko | AL | Britton | Porcello | Kluber | Verlander | Sale |
| Ryan Divish | AL | Porcello | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Britton |
| Sam Mellinger | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Britton |
| Scot Gregor | AL | Kluber | Porcello | Happ | Britton | Verlander |
| Shi Davidi | AL | Verlander | Kluber | Britton | Porcello | Sale |
| Stephen Nesbitt | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Bumgarner | Kershaw |
| Steve Gilbert | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Syndergaard | Bumgarner |
| straw_ryno | AL | Verlander | Sale | Kluber | Quintana | Sanchez |
| Thomas Harding | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Cueto | Bumgarner | Hendricks |
| Tim Brown | AL | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Verlander | Britton |
| Todd Dybas | NL | Scherzer | Bumgarner | Lester | Cueto | Hendricks |
| Todd Rosiak | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Cueto | Hendricks | Syndergaard |
| Todd Zolecki | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Fernandez | Bumgarner | Syndergaard |
| Tom Haudricourt | NL | Scherzer | Hendricks | Lester | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Wallace Matthews | AL | Porcello | Britton | Kluber | Verlander | Sale |
| Zack Meisel | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Tanaka |