Cy Young Ballots
| Voter | Year | Lg | 1st | 2nd | 3rd | 4th | 5th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Adam Berry | 2018 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Adam Rubin | 2015 | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | deGrom |
| Adam Rubin | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Harvey | Kimbrel | Wainwright |
| AJ Cassavell | 2019 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Flaherty | Ryu | Strasburg |
| Alex Pavlovic | 2016 | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Hendricks | Kershaw |
| Alex Pavlovic | 2018 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Alex Pavlovic | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Zimmermann |
| Alex Pavlovic | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Gonzalez | Cain |
| Alvin Valdez | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Cain | Lohse |
| Alyson Footer | 2019 | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Amanda Comak | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Lee | Kimbrel | Zimmermann |
| Andrew Baggarly | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Andrew Baggarly | 2015 | NL | Kershaw | Arrieta | Greinke | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| Andrew Gruman | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Greinke | Zimmermann |
| Andrew Wagner | 2018 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Freeland | Nola | Hader |
| Andy McCullough | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Anthony Castrovince | 2018 | AL | Verlander | Snell | Kluber | Sale | Bauer |
| Anthony DiComo | 2018 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Anthony Fenech | 2018 | AL | Verlander | Snell | Cole | Kluber | Diaz |
| Anthony Fenech | 2016 | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sale | Kluber | Britton |
| Anthony McCarron | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Greinke |
| Anthony Witrado | 2013 | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Sale | Sanchez | Colon |
| Barney Hutchinson | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Fister |
| Barney Hutchinson | 2015 | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | Cole | Bumgarner |
| Ben Goessling | 2012 | AL | Verlander | Price | Hernandez | Sale | Darvish |
| Ben Nicholson-Smith | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Severino | Carrasco | Verlander |
| Bernie Miklasz | 2015 | NL | Arrieta | Kershaw | Greinke | Cole | Scherzer |
| Bernie Miklasz | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Cueto | Zimmermann | Strasburg |
| Bernie Miklasz | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Lee | Harvey | Fernandez |
| Bernie Miklasz | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Cueto | Gonzalez | Lohse |
| Bernie Wilson | 2015 | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Cole | Melancon |
| Bernie Wilson | 2016 | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Bumgarner | Fernandez |
| Bill Ballou | 2012 | AL | Price | Verlander | Weaver | Hernandez | Harrison |
| Bill Center | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Kimbrel | Chapman |
| Bill Chastain | 2016 | AL | Porcello | Britton | Kluber | Sale | Tanaka |
| Bill Madden | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Severino | Carrasco | Stroman |
| Bill Madden | 2018 | AL | Snell | Kluber | Treinen | Verlander | Severino |
| Bill Plunkett | 2019 | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Strasburg | Gray |
| Bill Plunkett | 2015 | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | deGrom | Scherzer |
| Bill Plunkett | 2012 | AL | Price | Weaver | Verlander | Rodney | Sale |
| Bob Dutton | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Hernandez | Archer |
| Bob Dutton | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Verlander | Carrasco | Severino |
| Bob Klapisch | 2015 | NL | Greinke | Arrieta | Kershaw | deGrom | Scherzer |
| Bob Klapisch | 2013 | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Sanchez | Sale | Iwakuma |
| Bob Klapisch | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kershaw | Cueto | Kimbrel |
| Bob McManaman | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Zimmermann | Harvey | Greinke |
| Bobby Nightengale | 2018 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Nola | Freeland | Corbin |
| Brendan Kennedy | 2016 | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sanchez | Tanaka | Kluber |
| Brendan Kennedy | 2014 | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Hughes |
| Brian Costa | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cueto | Kimbrel |
| Brian McTaggart | 2019 | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Lynn | Giolito |
| Brittany Ghiroli | 2018 | AL | Snell | Verlander | Kluber | Sale | Bauer |
| Bruce Jenkins | 2012 | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Sale | Hernandez |
| Bruce Levine | 2017 | AL | Sale | Kluber | Kimbrel | Verlander | Santana |
| Bruce Miles | 2016 | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Syndergaard | Fernandez |
| Bruce Miles | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Kimbrel |
| Bruce Miles | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Cueto | Kershaw | Gonzalez | Cain |
| Bryan Hoch | 2019 | AL | Verlander | Cole | Morton | Bieber | Lynn |
| Bryan Hoch | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Severino | Carrasco | Verlander |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | 2016 | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Bumgarner | Hendricks | Cueto |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | 2015 | NL | Arrieta | Greinke | Kershaw | Scherzer | Cole |
| C. Trent Rosecrans | 2019 | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Flaherty | Scherzer | Gray |
| Chad Jennings | 2012 | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Sale |
| Charles Odum | 2019 | NL | deGrom | Ryu | Scherzer | Strasburg | Soroka |
| Chris Iott | 2013 | AL | Scherzer | Iwakuma | Darvish | Sanchez | Holland |
| Chris Iott | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Archer | Sale |
| Chris Jenkins | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Fernandez | Greinke | Harvey | Kimbrel |
| Chris Jenkins | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Cueto | Cain | Kershaw |
| Chris Mason | 2019 | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Bieber | Giolito |
| Chris McCosky | 2018 | AL | Verlander | Snell | Kluber | Sale | Cole |
| Chris McCosky | 2016 | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Kluber | Sale | Britton |
| Christopher Smith | 2016 | AL | Porcello | Verlander | Kluber | Britton | Happ |
| Colleen Kane | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Sale | Gray | Archer |
| Colleen Kane | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Severino | Carrasco | Verlander |
| Craig Davis | 2016 | NL | Scherzer | Lester | Hendricks | Fernandez | Kershaw |
| Dan Barbarisi | 2012 | AL | Verlander | Price | Weaver | Hernandez | Sale |
| Dan Barbarisi | 2014 | AL | Hernandez | Kluber | Sale | Lester | Price |
| Dan Connolly | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Severino | Carrasco | Verlander |
| Dan Hayes | 2016 | AL | Verlander | Porcello | Sale | Kluber | Britton |
| Dan Hayes | 2014 | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Sale | Lester | Scherzer |
| Danny Knobler | 2013 | NL | Kershaw | Wainwright | Fernandez | Greinke | Harvey |
| Danny Knobler | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Gonzalez | Kimbrel | Cueto | Kershaw |
| Daryl Van Schouwen | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Sale | Archer |
| Daryl Van Schouwen | 2019 | AL | Cole | Verlander | Morton | Lynn | Bieber |
| Dave Cameron | 2016 | NL | Kershaw | Scherzer | Syndergaard | Hendricks | Fernandez |
| Dave Cameron | 2015 | NL | Arrieta | Kershaw | Greinke | Scherzer | Bumgarner |
| Dave van Dyck | 2012 | AL | Price | Verlander | Hernandez | Sale | Weaver |
| David Barron | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Gray | Hernandez | McHugh |
| David Brown | 2018 | AL | Verlander | Snell | Sale | Bauer | Kluber |
| David Brown | 2017 | AL | Kluber | Sale | Kimbrel | Severino | Verlander |
| David Ginsburg | 2018 | AL | Verlander | Snell | Kluber | Sale | Cole |
| David Ginsburg | 2015 | AL | Keuchel | Price | Hernandez | Gray | McHugh |
| David O'Brien | 2019 | NL | deGrom | Strasburg | Flaherty | Ryu | Soroka |
| Dejan Kovacevic | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Cueto | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Gonzalez |
| Dennis Lin | 2019 | NL | deGrom | Scherzer | Ryu | Strasburg | Flaherty |
| Dennis Lin | 2014 | NL | Kershaw | Cueto | Wainwright | Bumgarner | Greinke |
| Dennis Manoloff | 2013 | AL | Scherzer | Darvish | Colon | Shields | Sale |
| Dennis Manoloff | 2012 | AL | Price | Verlander | Sale | Weaver | Harrison |
| Dennis Manoloff | 2014 | AL | Kluber | Hernandez | Scherzer | Sale | Lester |
| Dennis Punzel | 2012 | NL | Dickey | Kershaw | Kimbrel | Cueto | Gonzalez |